In 2000, Gregory Dutcher became Youth Pastor and eventually became Senior Pastor. Dutcher stepped in after Richard Shuey left his administrative role. Dutcher left unexpectedly to lead another church.
In 2004, Pastor Dave Shive stepped back into leadership to assist the congregation in seeking a new pastor. From 2004-2006, Wright Proctor, John Harris, and Roscoe Adams served as substitute pastors while the congregation sought a permanent leader.
In 2006, Loren Kraft became the lead pastor. Eventually, the church elders terminated Pastor Kraft, which caused a second split. From 2006 to 2008, Bob Vogel and other interim pastors led the church. This time of church division and searching for a new leader proved painful for the congregation.
In 2007, Stillmeadow developed the vision statement (include here).
In 2008, Stillmeadow hired Pastor Dave Gehret. Pastor Gehret gave a trial sermon and decided to serve Stillmeadow only if 100% of the trustees voted for him.
